Dating a Short Story

My office, the scene of tumultuous writing relationships

About a month and a half ago, inspired by a picture, I wrote a rough draft of a short story. About 2,300 words long, it had a nice beginning, a muddled middle, and an abrupt non-ending. I saved the story and closed the file. The story and I needed space from each other.

So, I wrote some blogs. I did minor revisions on a historical short story. I beta read a novel. I read some books. I played games with my grandchildren. I walked my dog. I watched TV. I cleaned the house.

That’s usually how it is for me at the beginning of a short-story relationship. I fall in love with an idea, which lives in my mind. I see a story with layered meaning, engaging characters, and a compelling plot. However, the vision in my head becomes incomplete and fragmented on the paper. Something gets lost in translation, and at this point, I’m never sure if I will ever meet the story I became infatuated with. It’s rare that a story and I click right away, so in the beginning, I often don’t name a story, just in case things don’t work out.

For a while, a rough draft and I will ignore each other. Then, if it’s meant to be, the story starts whispering in a corner of my mind. It nudges me when I’m drifting off to sleep. Before I open my eyes in the morning, I feel it staring at me. At this point, it’s all low-level noise. But if the story cares, it keeps calling to me, getting louder and louder, until the only way I can pacify it is to pull it up on my computer screen and spend time with it. My inspired-by-a-photo story is one of those types of stories — one that starts to follow me around.

So, last Saturday morning I returned to the story and spent hours with it. When I took my dog for a walk in the afternoon, I called a friend, who also writes. “I’m working on a story I started six weeks ago,” I told her. “It’s been painful.”

“It hurts?” she asked. I imagined her eyebrows pitching upward along with the sound of her voice.

“Yes,” I said, “I’m at the beginning stages of writing the story. I don’t know if it’s going to work or not, and that’s painful. If I can make the story work, then the revising and editing parts become fun.”

The painful phase happens almost every time I write a short story. My head spins. I crave chocolate. I check my email every five minutes. And I make excuses to leave my desk. But I’ve learned the only thing I can do is to keep returning to my story, to keep pushing forward. Sometimes after months of intermittently returning to a story again and again — trying to find a way into it, through it, or out of it — I get lucky, and my story seems to write itself. But this isn’t really true: It’s the time and work I’ve put in that suddenly makes the story feel like it’s flowing from my fingers. But not every short story I draft has a fairy tale ending. Some stories and I never see each other again, or after months of trying, we call it quits.

Last Saturday with my story felt like a bad date, and I reached a point where I had to bail. I left my office feeling I had wasted hours but determined to try again the next day.

On Sunday, I went back to the story. Back to tweaking the first couple pages, then getting up to do something, then back to the first couple pages, so I would know where I was at. Then up again. Then back to the first couple of pages. Who was I fooling? It was easier to spend time with my story’s charming beginning and overlook its flawed messy middle and nonexistent ending.

But I kept at it because when I’m writing, I consider banging my head against the wall to be part of my creative process.

After bumbling along with the story for a couple of hours on Sunday — I had been wrestling with the narrator’s voice and the story’s tense — an idea occurred to me. I revised the first few paragraphs, giving the narrator a distinct voice that seemed to fit the story’s theme and fix the tense problem at the same time. We’ll see.

For now, the story and I plan to keep seeing each other. We have coffee together in the mornings, before I pick up my grandchildren from summer school. Sometimes in the afternoon if my grandchildren are playing quietly, I sneak into my office and spend extra time with the story.

The relationship is progressing in a positive direction, but I’m not ready to declare it a love match, and the story remains unnamed. It could still turn out to be yet another frog that won’t become a prince.

(By the way, there is no reason to tell my short story that I hung out with a blog today.)

The photo that inspired my latest precarious relationship!

14 thoughts on “Dating a Short Story

  1. I chuckled all through this one. I know it all too well, from banging my head on the wall to getting up to do something else. My fridge is too close.

    Best of luck with the story!

    Denise

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Yes! Picture and process and honesty in the creation of a piece of writing. Very reassuring to a current writer, reassuring to a beginning writer (you are normal if you look/feel/think like this) and nostalgic if there is ever a lull in the tempestuous addiction (it rides you) to write. A good, good morning reading this, Vickie.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a comment